10 Lessons I’ve Learned Helping 1,000 Property Managers Grow Their Inventory
Recently, we just crossed a big milestone… our 1,000th partner.
As I’ve been reflecting on that, it hit me:
We’ve had a front-row seat inside more vacation rental companies, specifically around inventory growth, than anyone else in the industry.
We’ve seen what works.
We’ve seen what doesn’t.
And we’ve seen the patterns that separate the companies that scale… from the ones that don’t.
So I wanted to capture it.
Here are 10 lessons I’ve learned helping 1,000 property managers grow their inventory.
- Cheap Data is Expensive
- The 7 Key Messaging Building Blocks of Owner Marketing
- Build a Brand that is Slightly Better than you Actually are
- You Can’t Scale what you can’t Measure: Understanding Your Key Metrics
- Never Stop Marketing: The Compounding Power of Consistency
- Your Secret Weapon: Finding the Right Biz Dev Person
- The Fortune Is in the Follow Up: Respond Fast and Never Give Up
- Build a Referral Machine: Unlock a Recurring Stream of New Owners
- The Rule of Reciprocity: Be the Resource and Watch It Come Back Tenfold
- Be Remarkable: Differentiate and Build a Reputation So Strong It Sells For You
1. Cheap Data is Expensive
It all starts with data.
I’d argue 50% of your marketing comes down to your list.
If you’re targeting the wrong properties…
- homes that aren’t actually short-term rentals
- owners you’d never want
- bad or outdated contact info
You’re not just wasting money.
You’re multiplying it.
Because every bad record gets hit again and again…direct mail, email, digital… it all adds up.
This is where most people get it wrong:
They optimize for cheap data upfront,
instead of the total cost of marketing behind it.
That $0.10 record isn’t cheap after you:
- print it
- mail it
- follow up on it
- and get nothing
At the same time… this isn’t about making your list smaller.
It’s about making it right.
Better data = more efficient spend, better leads, lower cost per deal.
Cheap data feels efficient.
But it usually costs you more in the end.
2. The 7 Key Messaging Building Blocks of Owner Marketing
This is the baseline.
I’ve seen brand new property managers use this to build their entire rental program…
from their management agreement… to their tech stack… to their website.
It becomes the business plan on a one-pager.
And every time we onboard a new partner, we begin here:
Messaging.
Because it doesn’t matter what kind of marketing it is.
If the messaging isn’t right… none of it works.
Every piece of marketing needs these 7 building blocks:
- Features & Benefits — What are the core components of your rental program? What do you do, and why does it matter to the owner?
- Unique Selling Proposition — Why you vs everyone else? What actually makes you different?
- Trust Icons — These establish credibility instantly, often subconsciously. Think: Airbnb Superhost, Vrbo Premier Host, BBB A+, 4.9 stars on Google, VRMA membership, etc…
- Social Proof — People trust what others say about you more than what you say about yourself. Strong testimonials reduce the need for owners to “figure it out” on their own.
- Compelling Offer — Give them a reason to act now. The offer should be strong enough to stop them in their tracks.
- Call to Action — Tell them exactly what to do next. Every piece of marketing should drive a clear, simple action.
- Risk Reversal — Remove fear. Guarantees, flexibility, or anything that lowers the perceived downside. Eliminate friction when they are ready to sign-up.
Miss one… and performance drops.
I’ve seen great companies struggle. Not because they lacked a strong service,
but because they were missing 1–2 of these in their marketing.
The best operators don’t guess.
They build every campaign off this framework.
3. Build a Brand that is Slightly Better than you Actually are
I learned this from the master Jason Sprenkle and what he did with 360Blue.
Owners decide within seconds if they trust you… or not.
And most of that decision happens before you ever speak to them.
So early on, you have to punch above your weight.
Look bigger.
Look more professional.
Look more established than you actually are.
Here’s what that looks like in practice:
- A great website — This is your first impression and your storefront. Invest here. Then invest more.
- Professional photography — Make the investment here. I realize this is now table stakes but really good looking photography can make a difference.
- Well-designed signage — If your market allows it, this becomes your distributed billboard
- Microsites for key communities/buildings — Own the perception of market share
- Uniformed team members — Your people are walking billboards. Make sure they are representing your brand properly.
- Wrapped vehicles — Buy or lease really good looking vehicles. Get them wrapped and keep them clean. Park them in driveways, in neighborhoods you have owners or want owners. I can’t tell you how many leads we received where the owner said “I see your vans everywhere.”
We’ve seen this over and over:
When you look like the leader…
owners assume you are the leader.
And that trust shortcut matters.
Especially early, when you’re still earning it.
This isn’t about being fake.
It’s about compressing the timeline between where you are and how you’re perceived.
Because perception drives opportunity.
And opportunity drives growth.
4. You Can’t Scale What You Can’t Measure: Understanding Your Key Metrics
If you don’t understand your numbers… you can’t scale.
It starts with one simple question:
What is a property actually worth?
At exit, a rule of thumb we’ve seen (credit to Jacobie Olin who has done more M&A than anyone in this space) is about ~$34K per property.
Not planning to sell? Then you need to understand Lifetime Value (LTV).
Let’s break it down:
- Average property does ~$50K in gross booking revenue
- You net ~10% to the bottom line → $5K/year in EBITDA
- Average homeowner stays ~10 years
That means:
LTV = $50,000 per property
Now look at it through a growth lens:
If your Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) is $5,000…
you just generated a 10x return.
If my financial advisor said I have an investment that is almost guaranteed to give you a 10x return, I’d back up a truck of cash and give it to him. You won’t find a better ROI out there.
But here’s the catch:
Year 1, you’re basically working for free.
You spend upfront… and the returns come later.
That’s the game.
This is where most operators get stuck…they don’t understand the J-Curve.
There’s a gap between investment and payoff.
It feels like it’s not working… until it does.
This is why if you really want to scale, you need to have cash reserves. The more you want to grow, the more money you need. Here’s what it looks like if you want to add 10 properties this year. Do you have that $50k to invest? If you do, look at the long-term payout at the end.
The operators who win:
- Know their LTV
- Know their CAC
- Track their LTV:CAC ratio religiously
- And have the conviction (and cash) to stay in the game
Because once it works… it compounds fast.
5. Never Stop Marketing: The Compounding Power of Consistency
My marketing mentor Gary Gigot (early Microsoft VP, namesake of Notre Dame School of Entrepreneurship) used to say:
“Constant pressure on the market.”
That’s the game.
You don’t stop marketing for guests.
So why would you stop marketing for homeowners?
But most people do.
They treat owner acquisition like “hunting season.”
Send a few postcards… run a campaign for a month… then stop.
Then they say: “It doesn’t work.”
It’s not that it doesn’t work.
You just didn’t do it long enough.
There’s a compounding effect to marketing.
And it starts with a simple truth:
The Rule of 7.
It takes ~7 touches before someone takes action.
That’s why you see:
- the same car commercials
- the same attorney ads
- over and over
Repetition builds trust.
Trust drives action.
But here’s where it gets hard:
The Valley of Disappointment.
There’s a gap between what you expect to happen…
and what actually happens.
- You expect results immediately (dotted line)
- Reality is slow, flat, and frustrating (solid line)
Most people quit in that valley.
They send 1–2 mailers…
don’t see instant results…
and move on.
The best operators do the opposite.
They keep going.
Because once it starts working…
it compounds fast.
You’ve seen this before.
A new home joins your program and inevitably, the owner calls two weeks in asking why it’s not fully booked.
Meanwhile, a similar home that’s been with you for 10 years is packed.
Same home. Same market.
Different time in the system.
Marketing works the same way.
Consistency builds momentum.
Momentum builds results.
Never stop.
6. Your Secret Weapon: Finding the Right Biz Dev Person
If you only do one thing… do this!
Hire the right person to own business development.
Get this right, and a lot of the rest usually takes care of itself.
They’ll:
- Find leads and fill-up pipeline
- refine messaging
- push follow-up
- uncover what’s actually working
- Get signed contracts
In many cases, it’s not you.
Either you don’t have the bandwidth…
or you’re not naturally wired for it.
And that’s okay.
This role requires a very specific profile:
- high energy
- resilient to rejection
- naturally persuasive
- High sense of urgency
- relentless in follow-up
- Motivated by incentives (eg money)
A true rainmaker.
We’ve had a lot of success using psychometric tools from Steve Trover with Predictive Index to find them.
Profiles I love for this role:
- Captains
- Persuaders
- Mavericks
When you find the right person, you feel it quickly.
More conversations.
More opportunities.
More deals.
Same company. Same market. Completely different results.
7. The Fortune Is in the Follow Up: Respond Fast and Never Give Up
“Can’t stop… won’t stop.”
Speed wins.
Whoever responds first… usually gets the deal.
We see this in the data over and over.
But here’s the mistake:
Most companies respond once… maybe twice… and stop.
Meanwhile, the high-growth companies:
- respond immediately
- follow up consistently
- and don’t give up
- Have long-term nurture sequences setup in their CRM & marketing automation software
Because most owners don’t reply the first time.
Or the second.
Or even the third.
Life gets in the way. Timing isn’t right. They forget.
That doesn’t mean they’re not interested.
It means you need to keep showing up.
I say this all the time… and it still gets missed.
Most deals aren’t lost to competitors. They’re lost to silence.
The companies that win are the ones that are:
fast + persistent.
And if you’ve done point #6 right…
this gets solved.
A great Biz Dev rep lives in follow-up.
They don’t stop!
8. Build a Referral Machine: Unlock a Recurring Stream of New Owners
One solid referral can turn into dozens of new deals per year.
It’s the gift that keeps on giving.
The best operators don’t “hope” for referrals.
They build a system around them.
Start with your ecosystem:
- Realtors
- Builders
- Interior designers
- Home improvement contractors
- Mortgage Originators
And don’t forget your vendors.
Some of the best deals we’ve ever seen came from:
housekeepers, maintenance techs, or home services companies.
They’re in the homes.
They see everything.
They know who’s unhappy.
Treat them well.
Host vendor appreciation events.
Build real relationships.
Then activate your team:
Your employees are walking billboards.
- Make sure they look professional
- Give them cards
- Encourage them to talk about what you do
And most importantly:
Pay for it.
If someone refers a homeowner that signs… reward them.
As Charlie Munger said… “Show me the incentives, I’ll show you the outcome”
Done right, this becomes a flywheel:
- more relationships
- more referrals
- more deals
And over time, it becomes a self-sustaining growth engine.
9. The Rule of Reciprocity: Be the Resource and Watch It Come Back Tenfold
You’re going to be in this business for a long time.
Play the long game.
One of the most powerful principles in marketing comes from Robert Cialdini’s book Influence:
The Rule of Reciprocity.
When you give something of value… people naturally want to give something back.
The best operators lean into this hard.
They don’t gate everything.
They don’t hold back.
They teach the market.
They become THE resource.
And over time… it comes back.
Here’s what that looks like in practice:
Give value at scale:
- Build a rental projection calculator on your website
- Create a complete guide to STR regulations
- Publish a quarterly “state of the market” report
- Map top properties for sale that would make great rentals (with pro formas)
Show up in the community:
- Host homeowner (and future homeowner) events
- Teach classes at real estate schools
- Launch a podcast
- Build a local Facebook group (like Ginger at Beachball — 200K+ followers)
Create memorable moments:
- Free family portraits on the beach
- Custom art prints of their home
- Photobooks of their property
Most people won’t act immediately.
That’s not the point.
You’re building:
- trust
- goodwill
- and familiarity
So when the time comes…
they already know who to call.
10. Be Remarkable: Differentiate and Build a Reputation So Strong It Sells For You
What makes you different?
Because if you’re doing the same thing as everyone else…
you’ll get the same results as everyone else.
Early on, we leaned hard into this.
At Vantage, we did things nobody else in our market was doing:
- Delivered a USA Today to every guest’s door each morning
- Offered a “Sunny Day Guarantee” — rainy weather = refund (funded with weather insurance)
- Partnered with a local gym for free memberships
My friend Sean McGregor took it even further:
He only charges a commission if the guest leaves a 5-star review.
That’s remarkable.
Here’s the key:
You don’t market your way into differentiation.
You build it into the product.
If it’s not baked into your business…
no amount of marketing will fix it.
Because:
Marketing is just a microphone.
You still need something worth amplifying.
One of my favorite ideas from the book Blue Ocean Strategy is this:
Create a business where you don’t have competitors.
We did this with Purpose-Built Vacation Rentals:
- Designed, built and furnished the best performing homes
- Sold them to owners
- Then brought them into our rental program
They became the top-performing homes in the market.
These 25 homes did more than most 100+ unit portfolios.
And not once did someone ask about our commission or negotiate our fees.
That’s what happens when you’re truly different.
You can also layer in unique value:
- Give new owners access to something like 3rd Home
- Turn one property into access to thousands around the world
And don’t forget:
Reputation is everything.
Great reviews don’t just happen.
You have to:
- ask for them
- systematize them
- promote them
They drive trust… and they drive SEO.
Finally — talk to your customers.
Interview:
- 10 current owners
- 10 self-managing owners
Understand what they love, what they hate, and what’s missing.
Then reverse engineer the ideal program.
You’ll find your best ideas there.
End of the day:
Different wins.
Better isn’t enough.
After working with 1,000+ companies, one thing is clear:
There’s no silver bullet.
And it’s hard work.
The gap between those who grow and those who don’t
isn’t talent, market, or even product.
It’s execution.
Day in. Day out.
Do the right things, long enough…
and the results follow.
Go get ‘em!