25 Strategies to Grow Your Short-Term Rental Inventory… That Aren’t Direct Mail
Direct mail is one of the most effective ways to generate new leads for professional vacation rental managers. I should know—at Vintory, we are the largest mailer of direct mail in the industry and we’ve sent over 1.25 million postcards in the past year, resulting in thousands and thousands of new management contracts for our partners.
But direct mail isn’t the only game in town.
If you're looking to diversify your acquisition strategy, here are 25 tactics that aren’t direct mail, that can help you grow your inventory in 2025:
- Host a homeowner appreciation event – Like Tom Goodwin at Mountain Laurel Chalets and have them invite their friends and neighbors who may become future homeowners in your rental program. Here's a post from Tom describing it.
- Send a local magazine subscription – A full year of branding in their mailbox for under $20. I did a post on this previously. Check it out here.
- Offer a Homewatch service – Launch a Homewatch service to build trust with non-renting homeowners. Eventually many of them will need to start renting for one reason or another and you’ll be their first option because you’ve already built trust and credibility with them.
- Claim your free listing on Comparent – Showcase your company on the most visited marketplace on the planet where homeowners are actively looking for professional management.
- Host an off-season homeowner summit – Teach homeowners how to invest in the right homes and furnish their properties to maximize performance.
- Start a local Facebook group – Ginger Harrelson at Beachball Properties created several Facebook groups like “What’s Happening Orange Beach” and now has 200K+ members. This has been a major source of new leads for Beachball Properties.
- Offer free family portraits – Hire a photographer and invite owners for a photo day.
- Run personalized email campaigns – Yes, cold email still works…when done right. Vintory does this for all of our partners and it’s one of the most economical sources for new homeowners.
- Send high-end gift baskets – Create a list of your A+ property targets (think north of $150,000 in GBR) and target them with memorable, custom gifts. Yes it’s expensive marketing but the payoffs could be huge.
- Create custom art prints of local homes – Hire a professional photographer to take photos of your top targets and use artistic filters and frame these pictures and mail to prospective owners.
- Partner with realtors by promoting them inside your rentals - This one is from my friend Steve Schwab at Casago. Partner with Realtors and for every property they refer your way, highlight the realtor in the home and let them be the star (QR codes of top properties on the market, welcome baskets compliments from agent, email confirmations have realtors info, etc….). As guests fall in love with the area, they become buyer leads—creating a win-win flywheel that brings you more homes to manage.
- Instantly reveal contact info on Airbnb and Vrbo – We’ve developed a new technology codenamed BlueBox that allows you to instantly reveal the contact info for many of the homes listed on Airbnb, Vrbo and Zillow.
- List your company on Google Business and gather reviews – I’ve seen organic google rankings increase significantly after getting a couple reviews and it compounds for every new review.
- Park branded vehicles in key areas – Visibility creates credibility. If you have good looking logo’d vehicles, leave them in communities or properties that are vacant where you want to target. When I worked at the largest management company in Orlando, one of the number one sources of new homeowners was “I see your trucks everywhere!” We would just leave our trucks in the driveways of our vacant properties and they’d be seen by homeowners.
- Treat cleaners and maintenance teams like gold – Contract cleaners and maintenance people have contracts with individual owners. If you treat them well, they will refer those owners your way. At Vantage, this was one of our top referral sources of new homes.
- Create micro-sites for specific communities – Create micro-sites for the top communities and buildings you want to market. I did this in Ocean City and it was a huge driver of new leads. We became the unofficial vacation rental company for those communities but the only way to get listed was to list with our management company.
- Partner with interior designers – They’re often first to know when a home is being prepped for short-term rental.
- Work with local builders – Get in early when new homes are going up.
- Simplify local STR regulations on your website – If your city has complex regulations, build the most comprehensive resource on your website that make it really easy for homeowners, potential homeowners, realtors and others in your area to do research. This is one of the most widely searched terms for owners and prospective owners and you’ll be top of mind when they’re ready to buy or start renting.
- Install tracking pixels on your PM landing page – Retarget visitors who come to your PM landing page with Facebook and Google retargeting. 85-95% of the traffic to your landing page doesn't fill out a form.
- Launch a podcast – Share strategies for maximizing vacation rental revenue in your market and become the trusted expert.
- List your services on Thumbtack – Yes, really. Many PMs are getting leads from here.
- Tap into Airbnb’s Co-Host program – Many homeowners want help managing their listings but aren’t ready to fully hand over the reins. Position yourself as a professional Co-Host to provide support with guest communication, pricing, and turnovers—then gradually build trust and transition them into full-service management clients.
- Find underperforming homes - Use AirDNA or Wheelhouse to find underperforming listings and let those owners know you can help them optimize their performance.
- Hire Vintory Fractional Business Development Reps – Vintory has a team of “Seal-Team 6” business development reps who can help you close new management contracts for you for a fraction of the price of a full-time rep.