50 Podcasts. 50 Lessons. One Big Milestone.
We’ve published 50 Podcasts on the Vintory Studio channel. To put that in perspective, less than 1% of podcasts that launch ever make it to episode 50. Let that sink in for a second.
Now I know for seasoned industry legends like Heather Bayer, Sarah Bradford, Tim Cafferty, Alex Husner, Annie Holcombe, Mike Sjogren, Emanuele Pani, Jasper Ribbers, Eric Moeller, Annette Grant and Sarah Karakaian, this might feel like just another notch on the mic. But for me, it’s a moment worth pausing for and celebrating.
Over the course of these interviews, I’ve had the privilege of sitting down with some of the most experienced leaders in the vacation rental world. We talked about lots of things but most importantly we talked about the mistakes they made. And I think this is incredibly important, because from your mistakes, is where you learn. It’s also refreshing knowing some of the best and the brightest all made the same mistakes like the rest of us.
So, to mark this 50-episode milestone, I’m sharing:
50 Mistakes from 50 Podcasts.
Each one is a lesson in disguise… a battle scar that turned into wisdom. Enjoy!
Strategy
- Begin with the end in mind - Find Jacobie, Ben, or Simon, and understand what truly drives the value of your business. Then get up every morning and aim at those targets. Jason Sprenkle, formerly with 360 Blue
- Not moving faster on new ideas. Allowing distractions to delay completion of good ideas. - CJ Stam with Southern Comfort Cabin Rentals
- Invest with the end goal in mind of one day selling your company. Get yourself out of the day-to-day even if you never sell.
- Be the complete package deal for yourself, your sanity, and your team. Valerie Gangas with Juniper Holiday and Home
- Moving into too many markets at once. We were very strong in the Orlando market and thought we could march into other markets and dominate. It’s not as easy as you think, and the owners and guests in the new market aren’t all that impressed by what you did somewhere else. Steve Trover
- Getting stuck in analysis paralysis, and moving too slowly. There often isn’t a “perfect decision”. And nearly all decisions can be undone or changed. - Tony Cappaert with Blue Maple
- Keeping the main thing the main thing. As an entrepreneur it’s easy to get shiny object syndrome and see lots of opportunities. We’ve chased some of those shiny objects and it cost us in terms of growth. You will reap tremendous benefits if you can stay relentlessly focused on the main thing. - Tony Stancato with Book N Gather
- YOU CAN ONLY BE A LOCAL IN ONE PLACE: When opening my first expansion city, I replicated my previous approach. However, I realized the importance of adapting to the unique homeowner expectations and local culture. Aligning with the community is key to achieving growth. - Steve Schwab with Casago
- Letting issues fester - I've learned that if you let guest or homeowner issues fester, it leads to a lot of unnecessary anxiety. Deal with it as soon as possible. - Mike Harrington with Carolina Retreats
- Not fully implementing EOS or similar business operating system that facilitated change management / improvements sooner. - CJ Stam with Southern Comfort Cabin Rentals
Team
- This business, as with so many others, remains very simply all about people. It contains a lot of other things but everything is wrapped up in good people. - Clark Twiddy with Twiddy
- Vendors are an extension of your team, treat them as such and share in the success - Lino Maldonado with Scenic Stays
- Waiting far too long to hire an “Integrator”. As a visionary founder, I held on to far too many tasks that I was not best suited for. I ultimately hired an amazing GM but really never achieved the “Visionary / Integrator one, two punch” that we advise today. - Steve Trover
- Losing talented people by failing to nurture their career goals - Robin Craigen with Moving Mountains
- Having people in the wrong seats. As our friend Steve Trover likes to say, you need to get the right people in the right seats. We had a few employees clearly struggling and we couldn’t figure out the issue until we analyzed their predictive index and learned they were in a position that was making them miserable. Once we moved them to a position that played to their strengths their attitude and work improved. - JJ King
- Not Challenging the Local-Only Mindset - Believing that all team members need to be local to excel can limit your talent pool. Remote professionals can often bring valuable expertise and perspective. - Dana M with Tahoe Signature
- Not delegating fast enough. It's often so much faster to do small repetitive things yourself instead of writing a procedure and teaching someone else to do it. Until that's all you do all day. — Dennis Goedheid with Casiola
- Waiting too long to implement a system/technique to hire the right people (Better Talent/CI) - Travis Wilburn with Stay Charlottesville
Finance & Accounting
- Accounting – Don’t wait to get a strong accounting team in place. It is the foundation of your data-driven metrics. Even when you’re small, start with great accounting. Clean-up is too hard. - Jason Sprenkle, formerly with 360 Blue
- Not trust accounting right out of the gates. This should be an industry standard regardless of whether it is required in a location. Strong financial controls are imperative. Steve Trover
Cleaning, Inspections, Laundry & Safety
- Not paying better attention to guest safety. I almost lost the company from just one guest safety incident.- Justin Ford
- When we first started, putting all of our eggs in one basket for cleaning (only hiring one subcontracting cleaning company). Ginger Harrelson with Beachball Properties
Communication, Feedback and Guest Marketing
- Don’t underestimate the importance of proactive communication to owners even when it’s bad news - Lino Maldonado with Scenic Stays
- Not setting the right expectations. It is natural to want to point out the positives and oversell a property, but that can really come back to haunt you when the guest arrives. Photography is a great way to say it without saying it. Show the ugly house next door, the bad bedrooms with the good ones, and anything else. Let the guest decide.- Debbie Lipscomb with Eastern Shore VR
- Refunding guests for (valid) complaints. It’s easy to just give money back, but does that really solve anything other than getting them off the phone? We began discouraging refunds and offering experiences instead. It signaled that we recognize no amount of money will change the guests bad experience, but we can offer to give you something more valuable. We would frequently give a sunset cruise, deliver kayaks, a crab feast or something that would take their mind off the negative and enhance their vacation. - Debbie Lipscomb with Eastern Shore VR
- Not taking frivolous guest complaints seriously. You have to remember that what is mildly displeasing to one guest may be a disaster for another. I learned to treat every problem with the same urgency. - Debbie Lipscomb with Eastern Shore VR
- Forgetting that phone calls trumps emails every time for difficult situations - Adam Norris with Blue Ridge Mountain Rentals
- Branding – You’re selling an experience, so lean into incredible branding early. Your brand should always make you look a little bit better than you are. Jason Sprenkle, formerly with 360 Blue
- Unexpected issues will come up in a home. How you deal with problems is how relationships with guests are created. While we all like a perfect home and perfect guest experience, when this happens we rarely speak to guests. When issues come up, showing empathy and quick response time leads to frequent communications and even great reviews. A perfect recovery from an incident might be more powerful than delivering a perfect home. - Andy Newman
- OTA bookings are NOT bad! Not a popular opinion in our industry, but it took me a few years to realize that the real cost per acquisition (CPA) for our direct bookings was actually almost twice as high than the commissions we paid to the OTA's in the highly competitive Orlando market. Analyze your costs and make sure that direct bookings are REALLY the way to go for your market. If not, embrace the OTA's, but manage them carefully so you don't get to depend on a single one of them. - Dennis Goedheid with Casiola
- In the hustle and bustle of running a busy company, I have not always put enough emphasis on proactively and regularly communicating with homeowners. Thankfully we are on week seven of a new vlog that goes out to keep our owners informed and connected. - Tom Goodwin Mountain Laurel Chalets
- I Didn’t Know My Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) By Channel Soon Enough: While I am a huge fan of throwing spaghetti at the wall to see what sticks, you simply must know your CAC. Early on, I would make decisions on gut or emotions - they weren’t usually correct. It is important to know how much a booking costs from your own website, Airbnb, or Vrbo. Once you know that, remove the emotions and scale the correct channels. Balancing CAC with lead diversification will inevitably lead to a healthier and more stable business. - David Angotti with SmokyMountains dot com
Inventory Acquisition
- Not dedicating a percentage of your income towards continuous owner acquisition. - Michael Pedenko with Stay Porter
- Waiting 10 years before I hosted a property owner gathering/party. Don't be afraid for your owners to gather together with you. It was not only a great retention tool, it helped with future property acquisition as well. - Justin Ford formerly with On the Water in Maine
- Not jumping into a CRM for owner acquisition soon enough. Tried everything else first because it all “sort of” worked. So much wasted time! (Can I say here how much we LOVE Vintory?) Jennifer Mucha with Arrived
- Not having a structured owner acquisition plan meant we failed to follow-up on leads that didn’t respond to receiving our owner package. We lost a lot of potential owners by not adding them to an email list and staying connected with them. - Heather Bayer
- I Wasn’t Consistent At Excellent Owner Marketing: Our company did a decent job at owner marketing, but consistency was an ongoing issue. The marketing was either too inconsistent or ordinary and didn’t stand out. If I had it to do over, I would have delivered consistent, innovative, and excellent marketing to keep the pipeline healthy and avoid the peaks and valleys on owner sales we experienced. In addition, I would have created the minimum acceptable standards for both homeowner marketing and our new units funnel along with a well-defined plan to achieve it. If I fell short on that KPI, I would have hired either a dedicated internal team member or a company like Vintory. - David Angotti with SmokyMountains dot com
Taking on the Wrong Owners & Inventory
- Do not wait too long to fire an owner. If you are feeling frustrated with them, so are your employees. If anyone is badgering your staff and has unrealistic expectations, cut them loose. You are better off, and they may be too. - Jodi Refosko Taylor, formerly with Taylor Made Vacation Rentals
- We’ve learned that if an owner isn’t the right fit from the start, they rarely become one over time. We should have been more selective from the beginning and trusted our instincts. - Rachel and Rob Alday
- YOUR HOMEOWNER SELECTION WILL DETERMINE YOUR SUCCESS AND HAPPINESS -Taking on the wrong owners hurts. Owners should be consulted on product decisions and customer recovery choices. A misaligned owner taints the ability to offer quality service that reflects your vision. - Steve Schwab with Casago
Technology
- TECHNOLOGY SHOULD MAKE US BIONIC: Previously, finding property management software results was difficult. But with tech advancements, we gained efficiency at the expense of human connection. Casago prioritizes the human touch, love for homeowners, and genuine hospitality to restore that essential element. - Steve Schwab with Casago
- Build out your tech for the company you want to be not the company you are at the time. What tech you choose amplifies your growth, and is no fun changing PMS's at 140+ properties. - Andrew Pokrzywinski with Joseph Ellen Properties
Networking, Conferences, Community & Local Competition
- Being unaware of the industry knowledge via podcasts, attending conferences, and retreats. Stay curious. Endless ah-ha moments! - Valerie Gangas with Juniper Holiday and Home
- Not inviting my competitors for coffee. It wasn't until I built alliances with my competitors - that we all started to succeed together. Your competitors aren't your enemy. There are plenty of properties for everyone to manage. - Justin Ford formerly with On the Water in Maine
- Not joining peer groups sooner to appreciate that my business challenges are dwarfed by others. - Brian Zerges
- TODAY’S COMPETITION IS KEY TO TOMORROW’S GROWTH - I underestimated the value of befriending competitors. Building trust and caring for them has fueled my growth. While remaining competitive, I offer honest advice and cheer for their successes. - Steve Schwab with Casago
- Investing too little in conferences and networking. The relationships I build going to conferences almost ALWAYS generate so much more value than the cost of the ticket & travel. It’s a big investment & time suck, but always worth it. - Tony Cappaert with Blue Maple
Bonus: Take care of yourself, don’t take it personally and don’t forget to celebrate the wins!
- Thinking that the business won’t run without the founder/owner and therefore not being able to take a break or a holiday. One needs to delegate to keep the head clear. -Simon Lehmann
- Forgetting why you got into the business and only focusing on the problems. Constantly find joy in what you do. Have fun while doing it. Celebrate the wins!
- Don’t take yourself too seriously, you’re selling vacations for heavens sake… Lino Maldonado with Scenic Stays